Land+Living
Land+Living
"A Building as a Beacon for a City's Plans"
NY Times architecture critic Nicolai Ouroussoff reviews the new Caltrans building by Morphosis
Roland Halbe, LA TimesIn a review of the new Caltrans District 7 Headquarters building in downtown Los Angeles, Nicolai Ouroussoff touches on some ideas that are pertinent to our earlier posting about "lifestyle centers" and the privatization of public spaces. The building is an important new modern design and the article is worth the read (and browse through the slide show) even if you are not interested in our little diatribe about retail developments.
Like most American cities... [Los Angeles] has had to cope with increasing pressures from developers and urban planners, who tend to see urban space as nothing more than a vast machine for middle-class consumers. In this context Mr. Mayne's revamped Modernism has a refreshing honesty.

Article: NY Times - A Building as a Beacon for a City's Plans
Firm: Morphosis
Reference: Reality Bites (Land+Living)

...Mr. Mayne [does not] accept the notion that to save our urban centers, we must transform them into ersatz versions of small-town America with themed pedestrian environments. On the contrary, his design sprouts from an intuitive understanding of what gives cites their meaning: their clashing scales and vibrant ethnic mix.
...the building's relentless focus on public space reinforces Mr. Mayne's social mission. An unrepentant child of the 1960's, Mr. Mayne has long been obsessed with the ideals of early Modernism, particularly its utopian goals. This, more than anything else, has inspired him to tackle the big government projects that many high-end architects shy away from. In the process he has become adept at breathing new life into old Modernist formulas.


 Comments (4)
Richard  — June 7, 2005
Caltrans Building Los Angeles
Unfortunately I live close to this CalTrans building. It’s the most aggressively ugly building I’ve ever been exposed to. It’s dismal, scary, depressing and very, very large. In Los Angeles architects use buildings as weapons against us.
back to top ↑
Craig  — January 4, 2006
Cal Trans Building
I work in City Hall, only a block from the building and I'm actually quite fond of it. I couldn't agree more with the Morphosis resistance to making cute "urban" spaces with faux-classic touches. Though massive, concrete and steel, the spaces in and around the building are beautiful, and I dare say, inviting. That and it looks like the freeway in plan view for Christ's sake! What's not to like? Personally I am proud to have it in the Civic Center.
back to top ↑
Laura  — January 4, 2006
Caltrans Building
Perhaps Richard (above) should move to a less architecturally hostile location . . . such as Idaho? Alaska maybe? I believe those states stick to more conventional weapons like knives and guns. The Cal Trans building rocks. I love it.
back to top ↑
erik  — January 9, 2006
caltrans of la
to belive that people look at a building and think how ugly is that is unimaginable to me. the reason being that i was one of only two people who fabricated the more that ten thousand pannels that clad the outside of this historic building. so i do take alot of pride when it comes to this building. it took us six months to form the pannels running twenty hours a day. curently i am helping finish the restoration at the grifith obsrevitory
back to top ↑